Your Neighborhood Cookie Shop

Decorated Sugar Cookies

Standard Gift Assortments ~ 1 dozen individually wrapped cookies in bakery box  $26.95

Standard Favors ~ Individually wrapped cookies in cellophane bag with ribbon, message tag (optional), minimum order = 1 dozen per design Prices start at $2.35 per cookie


Specialty Decorated Sugar Cookies

Pricing starts at $24.95/dozen (loose in bakery boxes). An album of design choices will be featured in the store.  Contact us for exact pricing!

Custom Decorated Sugar Cookies

$20 customization fee plus specific quoted cookie price. Schedule a consultation with Katie to decide on designs, pricing, etc.


Nick Bombich

“You can really tell Katie pours her heart in to each cookie she makes and delivers as her love for her business and craft shows in everything she does with Give Mia Cookie. We are looking forward to enjoying her cookies for many years to come.“

Samantha McVicker

“Give Mia Cookie has the most beautiful cutout cookies around, and they taste AMAZING!  My family is full of bakers, and we will never make a cutout sugar cookie again after having these– there is no point, these cookies are perfect!! “


Tutu or Tie (Gender Reveal)


Monsters – Match Invite


Lucy is 1 (Owls)

Happy 40th Jonathan Arcade


Bridal Shower To Match Decor

Ben is 1 – Matching Invite

Baby Animals On Circles To Match Bedding



Winter _

Winter _



Valentine _




Summer _




Easter _




Zoo Animals

Under The Sea

Time Flies

Ties Mustaches

Thomas The Train

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles





Sesame Street



Mickey Minnie

Ladybugs Bees

Hungry Caterpillar



Dr. Seuss

Dr. Seuss_

Crayon Assortment


Collegiate (feature Penn State cookies)




Baptism 1st Communion

Happy Birthday Boy


Circle with Initials or Monogram

Bridal Shower

Bridal Shower_




Baby _

Baby _


Shop Faq’s

• Where are you located and what are your hours?

We are located on Library Road in Bethel Park, PA.  Right near the large intersection of South Park Rd, Baptist Rd, Library Road(Rte. 88), and Corrigan Drive.  There is a Papa John’s Pizza Shop on the corner and our building is right behind theirs.  Our store hours are Tuesday-Thursday 9 am-6 pm, Friday & Saturday 9 am-8pm, CLOSED on Sunday & Monday.  During cookie seasons (Easter, Valentine’s Day, Christmas, etc) we will offer extended hours.


• Do you have parking available?

Yes!  We have 9 parking spots available….and our building is completely handicapped accessible as well.


• What can I expect to find at your shop?

You will find a place where you are welcome to come in and enjoy a snack or just quickly pick up an order while you are out running errands.  For detailed information about the shop, visit this page: About the Shop.


• What types of payment do you accept?

We accept cash, visa, mastercard, american express, discover, and personal checks.  We can also accept paypal upon request.

Product Faq’s

• What are the ingredients of your sugar cookies?

The ingredients for the sugar cookies are as follows: 

 Unbleached All Purpose Flour, Butter, Vegetable Shortening,

Sugar, Eggs, Pure Vanilla Extract, Pure Almond Extract, Baking Powder, Salt, Confectioner’s Sugar, Pasteurized Egg White,

Corn Syrup, Glycerin, FD&C Red#40 & #3, Yellow #6 & #5, and Blue #1 & #2

All cookies are made on equipment that may contain nut and peanut traces


• Do your cookies really taste good? 

Yes!  The sugar cookie remains soft and chewy and the icing is the perfect sweet touch to compliment the cookie.

• Do I have to pre-order my cookies or do you have cookies available for purchase all the time?

We have both assorted cookies and sugar cookies in stock at the shop all the time….but if you would like a particular shape or design then it is very very important to pre-order.  For specialty and custom orders we typically require at least one week’s notice.  There is a decorating process for sugar cookies which includes specific amounts of drying time per layer/color of icing.  Rush orders may not be possible based on what your design request is.  We will always do our best to accommodate your requests….but please understand that this is not a quick process!



• How much notice do you require for special cookie orders?

The more notice you can give us, the better!  We always recommend that as soon as you know the event date and the approx. qty. of cookies needed, contact us to reserve a spot on the cookie schedule, especially if it is a large event like a wedding or corporate event.  During busy times of the year it is quite possible that we will shut-off the ordering completely once the cookie schedule is full.  We will never ever sacrifice our quality in order to take on more projects each week.

• What is the minimum order quantity for a special cookie order?

The minimum quantity for custom cookie orders is one dozen per design.  For example, if you are having a wedding shower and you would like cookie favors for 36 guests then you can select up to three different designs and get 12 of each. You can certainly request lesser minimums, but there may be additional charges that will apply….especially if each design requires different colors of icing.  When in doubt, just ask!  We are happy to discuss exactly what you’d like and come up with a good solution.  

• How do I place an order?

You can place an order by calling us directly at (412)831-1616 or by emailing us at  By emailing or calling you can reserve a spot on the cookie schedule.  Please note….your spot on the cookie schedule is not officially held until you receive a return-email from us or until you speak with someone over the phone.  Simply sending an email or leaving a voicemail does not confirm an order. 


• Do you ship cookies?

We do offer shipping within the continental U.S.  We use UPS ground services(or expedited shipping options if you choose). We package the cookies very well to ensure safe transit, but there are still risks involved with shipping a fragile product, as we never quite know what each individual package may go through in transit.  Shipping and handling charges start at $14.95 and may increase based on the quantity of cookies and the destination to which they are going.  For additional shipping information contact us and we can discuss your individual needs.

• What are your prices?

Our prices range based on the size of the cookie and the intricacy of the design.  We have some set prices for particular assortments and favors, which can be found HERE or you can view our cookie book at the shop.  As for custom designs, the pricing will be decided upon during a consultation with Katie, depending on what exactly your cookie request entails.  For a price quote, just email us at and include as many details as possible about what you’d like.  Then we can get back to you with an approximate price quote.

• Do you offer coupons or discounts?

We will offer coupons and discounts periodically to our facebook and twitter followers. Make sure to follow us for the most up-to-date offers.

Meet The Owner

give mia cookie 01432 Katie


Hi!  My name is Katie and I am the proud owner of Give Mia Cookie, a sweet little neighborhood cookie shop located in the heart of the South Hills of Pittsburgh.  I say the “heart” of town…because this is my hometown, Bethel Park, PA…and my heart truly belongs here.


My husband Rob and I both grew up here in Bethel Park.  We both left town to follow our collegiate dreams, he at WVU and myself at Syracuse University.  I obtained my bachelor’s degree in retail management with a focus of study on visual merchandising & retail buying.  Once college was over I was drawn to come back to Pittsburgh because of the love for my family, my city, and of course my fiancé!  Rob and I were married in 2006 and we started planting our roots right here in Bethel Park, where we still reside today with our 3 year old daughter Mia and our lovable dog Layla.   When I was pregnant in 2010 is when this cookie adventure really began….because I made my first ever decorated sugar cookie for my very own baby shower favors!  In August of 2010 we were blessed beyond belief when our daughter Mia was born. While embracing my new role of being a mom, I began to fall in love with cookie decorating, too….submerging myself in all things cookie-related and learning as much as I could by trial and error.  For 3 years I made cookies out of my home for friends and family, working late nights and early mornings so that I could still spend my days with my amazing daughter.  Mia became very curious about my hobby right around when she turned 2….so cookie decorating became something that I was able to share with and teach her. She’s a really great cookie decorator herself at the young age of 3!  She is amazingly bright and so brilliantly creative….sometimes she truly takes my breath away with her adorable expressions and her sweet words…and that is why this business carries her name.  She is my ultimate inspiration and means the world to me!  So after these past few years of growing my hobby into a business, it became clear that it was time to mix my love for cookie-making with my background in retail…and that is how my dream came true and Give Mia Cookie “the shop” was born.


I have so many hopes and dreams for this shop.  I hope that it is accepted and loved by the community that I love so much.  I wish to learn from each and every success and failure, and to make the shop better each and every day.  I dream that two people will meet here and fall in love…. and that my shop will forever be a part of their “story”.  I hope that my shop makes people smile.  I wish to be successful enough to be able to  give back to charities and foundations that I wholeheartedly believe in.  I dream that my daughter will be proud to work here one day….and that this shop will always feel like home to her.  I hope that my husband and I can one day look back on this family adventure and be so glad that we took this leap.


Lastly, I wish to be a part of your most special family moments… birthdays, neighborhood gatherings, dance recitals, sports banquets, graduations, and more.  Both the  momentous and everyday occasions that my cookies can help to celebrate and brighten.


From the bottom of my heart, thank you.  Hope to see you at the shop!


About The Cookie Shop

About The Cookie Shop


Give Mia Cookie is a locally owned neighborhood cookie shop, located in Bethel Park, in the south hills of Pittsburgh, PA.   We welcome you to stop into our shop to get the best view (and taste!) of what we offer.  Our famous decorated sugar cookies are a beautiful and delicious treat, but we also have classic favorites like oatmeal raisin and thumbprints…and also fun new recipes like s’mores bars and pb&j drops. We strive to offer you great tasting cookies for a quick snack… or for your most special occasions!


The Shop

Our shop is a lovely place to visit and enjoy.  Come in and enjoy an ice-cold glass of milk or a cup of locally roasted freshly brewed coffee. Cookie dunking in any beverage is strongly encouraged!  We feature a special medium-roasted coffee called “Give Mia Coffee” made by the amazing roasters at 19 Coffee Company.  Enjoy your snack while being comfortably seated at a cafe table or at a corner chair with a window view.  Our shop is completely kid-friendly….we love children of all ages….and children love cookies!  So we are the perfect stop for an after-school treat or a reward for playing an awesome t-ball game.


In addition to yummy cookies you will also find gift items such as mugs, milk glasses, and t-shirts which feature our adorable logo.  All items make great gifts! (especially if you know someone named Mia!)


Decorated Sugar Cookies

Our famous decorated sugar cookies are certainly our specialty. We start with our homemade vanilla-almond sugar cookie dough.  Each cookie is hand-rolled, hand-cut, and baked with a perfectly golden edge, all while maintaining a soft fresh texture.  The cookie is then hand-decorated with a royal glaze icing in any design or color!  The possibilities for designs are endless! We pride ourselves on serving sugar cookies that truly taste as good as they look!  Cookies are meant to be enjoyed and we will never sacrifice quality and taste!


Every-Day Designs

Each week we offer a variety of sugar cookies that are seasonably decorated and can be personalized on the spot for a quick gift. Maybe flowers in the springtime, footballs in the fall, snowflakes during those chilly months….you never know what designs we’ll display each week!  One thing’s for sure…we always have our signature cookie for sale…the yellow polka dot cookie from our logo!  The question is….which part do you eat first?  The head, the arms, or the legs? Totally up to you!


Special Orders

There are so many possibilities for cookie designs it’s impossible to list them all!  We have a book of standard and specialty design options or we can design something custom just for you!  We will gladly meet with you to go over all options of designs for your special event.  Whether it’s a dance party birthday bash or an elegant bridal shower, a company golf outing, or a family reunion celebration, we strive to create designs that will compliment your event theme and motif.  Whether packaged individually as party favors for your guests or displayed on cookie trays to be enjoyed at the party, our cookies are sure to make your event extra special and remembered.


Assorted Cookies

There is something for everyone at Give Mia Cookie.  Our assortment of cookies and bars may vary from week to week…we’re always coming up with fun new recipes!  You’ll be sure to find the classic favorites ready to buy…chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, thumbprints, and more!  For large orders or special requests just give us a call and we can have them freshly baked and ready to go.


Please contact us with any questions….we’re a friendly bunch!  Give us a call or send an email…we’ll get back to you just as soon as soon as we can.



twitter Twitter          facebook Twitter          email Twitter